We only show a price when the ranch publishes one. Today that's 3 of 40. Raise cattle? Get listed free →
Half Cow FinderBulk beef · straight talk
Comparisons

ButcherBox vs Buying a Half Cow: A Fair Comparison

Bulk beef isn't for everyone. Here's an honest look at when a subscription box makes more sense, and when it doesn't.

Heads up: some links on this page are affiliate links (Amazon and ButcherBox). If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which ranches we list or what we say about them. How we make money.

Side by side

Half cow from a ranchButcherBox subscription
How you payDeposit, then a balance at harvest. One large bill.A recurring box. Smaller bills, more often.
Freezer spaceA lot at once. A half usually wants a chest freezer.Fits in a kitchen freezer.
Choice of cutsYou choose on the cut sheet, within one animal.You choose from the company’s menu.
Where it comes fromOne ranch you can call, often one you can visit.A national supply chain the company manages.
Getting itPickup or local delivery, on the ranch’s schedule.Shipped to your door.
CommitmentOnce or twice a year.Ongoing until you change or cancel it.

How to compare price fairly

We don't print prices here, because both change. To compare honestly:

  1. Get the ranch's price per lb of hanging weight and the processing costs.
  2. Run them through the price calculator to get price per lb of take-home beef.
  3. Look up the current box price and its total pounds, and divide.
  4. Enter that number in the calculator's comparison box.

Keep in mind a half cow includes a lot of ground beef and roasts. Compare against a box with a similar mix, not an all-steak box.

Who each one suits

A half cow suits you if you have (or will buy) a chest freezer, cook a lot of ground beef, can pay a big bill once, and want to know the ranch.

A subscription suits you if you're short on freezer space, want smaller regular bills, or want to try grass-fed beef before committing to a whole share.

Still deciding? Try a quarter first, or split a half with friends. Here's how to split one.

Keep reading

All guides →